Signs it's time to replace your roof
Age is the first clue. InterNACHI's life-expectancy chart gives 3-tab asphalt shingles about 20 years and architectural shingles (the thicker, layered kind) about 30. Shoreline Roofing's 2026 metal guide puts asphalt at 15 to 22 years in damp, shaded Victoria conditions. If your roof is 18 years or older, look for these from the ground or from inside:
- Shingles curling, cupping or cracking across whole slopes, not just one patch
- Granules (the sandy coating) washing off and leaving dark, bald patches
- Leaks that come back in new places after repairs
- A sagging roof line, which can mean wet or rotten boards underneath
- Exposed or loose nail heads, and missing or damaged flashing (the metal that seals chimneys and walls)
- Moss mats thick enough to lift shingle edges
One or two of these on a single slope usually points to a repair. Several across the roof means patching is money spent on a roof that's finished.
What a full replacement includes
Every replacement quote we write lists these as separate lines. If another roofer's quote doesn't mention one, ask whether it's included or simply left out.
| Step | What it is | Why it matters on the South Island |
|---|---|---|
| Tear-off | Every layer of old shingles and underlayment stripped down to the deck | A buried second layer hides rot and adds weight. The deck has to be seen to be judged. |
| Sheathing check | Walking and sounding the sheathing (the plywood or boards the roof is nailed to) and replacing soft sheets | Forge Metal Roofing notes repair around eaves, valleys and old leak points is fairly common in this damp climate. |
| Underlayment | A synthetic or felt sheet laid over the whole deck before the shingles | The backup layer when wind pushes rain under shingle edges. |
| Ice and water shield | A self-adhering rubberized membrane bonded to the deck at the eaves and in the valleys | IKO's bulletin also calls for it around vent pipes, chimneys and along walls, the places water reaches first. |
| Flashing | Bent metal that seals chimneys, walls and valleys, replaced rather than reused | IKO's install guide says a roof most likely leaks where the shingle layer is penetrated, interrupted or meets a wall. |
| Ventilation | Intake vents at the eaves and exhaust at or near the ridge | Lets moist attic air out. Necessary, though not a cure-all in this climate (see the FAQ below). |
| Drip edge | A metal strip along the eaves and rakes (the sloped side edges) | Steers water off the edge instead of letting it wick back into the fascia boards. |
| Shingles, starter and ridge cap | Architectural shingles, a sealed starter course at the edges, capped hips and ridges | Edges and ridges are where winter wind gets under a shingle first. |
| Cleanup | Bin removal and a magnet sweep of the yard and driveway | Roofing nails in a lawn or tire are the last thing you should have to deal with. |
Ice and water shield was designed for ice dams, which Victoria rarely gets: the airport averages about 8 days of snowfall a year in Environment Canada's 1981 to 2010 normals. Here it does a different job, bonding to the deck in the valleys, eaves and penetrations where wind-driven rain runs heaviest. Skipping it is a shortcut nobody notices until a valley leaks.
Replacing a cedar shake roof
Plenty of older South Island houses still carry cedar shakes, and owners replacing them usually move to asphalt or metal roofing. We tear the shakes off completely; nothing goes over them.
The reason is the deck. The Cedar Shake and Shingle Bureau's application details allow shakes over spaced sheathing: 1x4 or 1x6 boards with gaps between them. That spacing suits wood shakes. IKO's asphalt installation guide calls for a deck that is smooth and free of gaps or holes. So after the tear-off we lay solid sheathing, plywood or OSB (oriented strand board) sheets, over or in place of the spaced boards before any underlayment goes down.
That new deck is a real line on the quote. A shake tear-off priced like a shingle tear-off is missing it, and the difference shows up later as an extra. If your home is heritage-designated in the City of Victoria, a change of roofing material is an alteration that needs Council approval, so settle that before choosing a product.
Want this priced for your own roof? We send written, itemized quotes.
Get a written quoteHow long it takes, and what happens to the house
Forge Metal Roofing's timeline guide puts asphalt on a typical detached house at one to three days on site, and a few weeks from signing to cleanup once ordering and scheduling are counted. Rain, a steep pitch, a second layer of old shingles and the amount of rotten deck are what stretch it. Your quote gives the estimate for your roof.
You can stay home. The work is outside, and we close every section the same day we open it. What you'll notice:
- Noise, loudest during tear-off
- A bin and a pallet of material in the driveway, so move cars out the night before
- Dust and grit falling into the attic, so cover anything stored up there
- Hammering carried through top-floor walls, so take down mirrors and framed pictures
Asphalt shingles bond to the course below through a heat-activated strip, and Forge's guide notes shingles rely on warm temperatures to seal. Winter re-roofs are normal here, but ask any roofer how shingles laid on a cold day are secured until those strips bond.
What a roof replacement costs
As of late 2026, two Victoria roofers' published pricing guides give these ranges: $9,000 to $30,000 for a full replacement across all materials (Shoreline Roofing, June 2026) and $12,000 to $40,000 or more (Forge Metal Roofing, 2026). Forge puts asphalt shingles at $5 to $9 per square foot installed. Those are published market ranges, not a quote for your house.
Our roof replacement cost guide breaks down what moves the number: roof size and pitch, layers to remove, deck repairs, and how cut up the roof is with valleys and dormers. The quote form gets you the real figure, itemized.
Do you need a permit to re-roof?
Sometimes, and the rules aren't uniform across Greater Victoria. Central Saanich's residential guide lists replacing roofing material as maintenance that needs no permit. Saanich's permit Q&A requires a permit to alter an existing building and doesn't name re-roofing either way. In Victoria, a heritage-designated house can't be altered without Council approval.
Structural repairs, a heavier roofing material or a change of material can bring a permit into play anywhere. We confirm with your municipality's building department before the job is scheduled, and if a permit is needed, it appears on the quote.

