Standing seam or metal shingles?
Two profiles cover nearly every house we'd put metal on. The Metal Roofing Alliance's style guide shows a wider range, including slate, tile and shake looks, but these two do the work on South Island homes.
| Profile | What it is | Fasteners | Where it fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standing seam | Long vertical panels running eave to ridge, joined by raised seams that lock together | Hidden clips under the seams, no screws through the face | Simple rooflines with few valleys; the premium option on price |
| Metal shingles (shake, slate or shingle look) | Pressed steel or aluminum panels shaped to look like traditional roofing; some are stone-coated | Varies by product; ask whether screws are hidden or exposed | Character houses, and cut-up roofs where long panels would look out of place |
| Exposed-fastener panel | Ribbed or corrugated sheets screwed through the face | Visible screws with rubber washers | Sheds and outbuildings. Shoreline Roofing notes more leak risk at the fasteners over time, and we don't put it on houses. |
Steel is the common base metal and costs less. Aluminum resists corrosion better, which Shoreline Roofing points out matters near the water, so for waterfront homes in Oak Bay, Sidney or along the Esquimalt shoreline we price aluminum as an option.
Metal roof cost Victoria BC
As of late 2026, the Victoria roofers that publish metal prices disagree by enough to matter, so here they are side by side. None of these figures is a quote.
- Per-square-foot prices apply to roof surface, which on a pitched roof is larger than the floor below it.
- At Forge's standing seam rate, each 1,000 sq ft of roof surface works out to $12,000 to $20,000 or more before extras. A 2,000 sq ft roof would be $24,000 to $40,000 or more.
- That sits above Shoreline's typical-home range partly because Shoreline's range also covers metal shingles and simpler profiles, which it says land lower than standing seam.
| Source (date) | Who they are | Metal price | Compared with asphalt |
|---|---|---|---|
| Forge Metal Roofing (2026) | Victoria metal roofing company | Standing seam $12 to $20 or more per sq ft installed; corrugated $8 to $14; aluminum and specialty $10 to $18 | About 1.5 to 1.8 times asphalt up front |
| Shoreline Roofing (July 2026) | Victoria roofer selling both asphalt and metal | $18,000 to $35,000 for a typical single-family home | Roughly double an asphalt re-roof |
| Metal Roofing Alliance (undated) | US metal roofing industry group | No dollar figure | Roughly two to three times asphalt |
Tear-off of old shingles or cedar shake, new sheathing (the plywood deck under the roof), the number of valleys and chimneys, and steel versus aluminum move your number within those ranges. For the full comparison, see metal vs asphalt roofing; for asphalt prices, see the roof replacement cost guide.
How long a metal roof lasts
A long time, but every lifespan figure comes from someone, and the sources selling metal tend to quote short lives for asphalt. Side by side:
| Source | Who they are | Metal | Asphalt |
|---|---|---|---|
| InterNACHI life-expectancy chart | Home inspectors' association | 40 to 80 years | About 20 (3-tab), about 30 (architectural) |
| Metal Roofing Alliance FAQ | Metal roofing industry group | 30 to 50 years or more | 12 to 20 years |
| Forge Metal Roofing (2026) | Victoria metal roofer | 40 to 60 (corrugated), 50 to 70 (standing seam) | 15 to 20 years |
| Shoreline Roofing (June 2026) | Victoria roofer, both materials | 40 to 50 years or more | 20 to 25 (standard), 25 to 30 (architectural) |
Our reading: metal outlasts asphalt by a wide margin, though not always by the three-to-one some metal sellers suggest. A fair comparison is 40-plus years of metal against 25 to 30 years of well-vented architectural shingles.
Want this priced for your own roof? We send written, itemized quotes.
Get a written quoteIs a metal roof loud in the rain?
Over a solid deck, not by much. McElroy Metal, a metal manufacturer citing acoustic research from LuleƄ University in Sweden, puts rain on asphalt shingles at about 46 dBA and rain on a metal roof at about 52 dBA. Metal over open framing, barn-style with no deck, measured about 61 dBA.
The source sells metal, so weigh the exact numbers accordingly. The structural point holds either way: the deck, the underlayment (the waterproof sheet between deck and metal) and the attic insulation do most of the quieting. We install metal over solid sheathing only.
Moss, wind and snow on the South Island
Moss: Oregon State University's extension guidance says moss doesn't grow easily on metal because the surface is too slippery for it to take root, and lists replacing shingles with metal as an option for roofs that keep growing it. On shaded lots under Garry oaks and firs, that is often the strongest argument for metal.
Wind: the Metal Roofing Alliance says quality metal systems can withstand gusts up to 140 mph (about 225 km/h), and quotes FEMA's advice to use tested systems with proven uplift resistance and the proper clips and fasteners. The rating only holds if the panels are attached the way they were tested, so ask any installer which system they use and whether clip spacing follows the manufacturer's layout.
Snow: Victoria International Airport averages about 40 cm of snowfall spread over 8 days a year in Environment Canada's 1981 to 2010 normals, so load is rarely the issue here. Sliding is. Metal sheds snow in sheets, so over doors, walkways, decks and parking spots we add snow guards, which the MRA notes clip onto standing seams without puncturing the panels.
Metal or asphalt for your house?
Metal makes the most sense if you plan to stay a long time, have a shaded, mossy lot, or are tired of re-roofing every couple of decades. It makes less sense on a short hold, a tight budget with other priorities, or a heritage-designated house, where a change of roofing material needs approval; in the City of Victoria, Council approval.
Ask and we price metal and asphalt side by side on the same written quote. The full comparison is on our metal vs asphalt page, and the quote form gets you numbers for your own roof.

