Metal vs asphalt roofing at a glance
We install both, so we have no reason to steer you toward either. Every row below comes from a named source, and where the source sells one of the two materials, we say so.
| Factor | Asphalt shingle | Metal |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | $5 to $10 per sq ft of roof installed (Forge Metal Roofing; Green Building Canada) | $12 to $25 for steel standing seam, $12 to $18 for steel metal shingle, $22 to $30 for aluminum (Forge; Green Building Canada; RenoQuotes) |
| Lifespan | About 20 to 30 years for architectural shingle, shorter on shaded, mossy slopes | 40 years or more; published figures run from 30 to 80 |
| Wind | Warranted to 177 km/h, or about 210 km/h with the maker's high-wind nailing (IKO Cambridge, Malarkey Highlander) | The Metal Roofing Alliance cites a 140 mph (225 km/h) rating |
| Moss and wet winters | Granular texture holds moisture and moss in shade; 'algae resistant' covers blue-green algae streaks, not moss (IKO's algae warranty is 10 years) | Smooth coating gives moss little grip; valleys and the high side of a chimney still collect debris |
| Rain noise | The quiet baseline | The Metal Roofing Alliance says there is little difference; we located no independent measurement |
| Weight | About 240 lb per 100 sq ft (Malarkey Highlander 242 lb, CertainTeed Landmark PRO 240 lb) | About half of asphalt, per the Metal Roofing Alliance |
| Repairs | Any shingle roofer can replace a few shingles | Needs a matching profile and colour and metal-specific skill |
| Appearance | Widest colour range and the familiar look | Standing seam reads modern; metal shingle can mimic shake or slate (Green Building Canada) |
| Resale | US 2025 data: an asphalt re-roof recouped about 76% of its cost at sale in the Pacific region | Same data: a metal re-roof recouped about 51% |
Full ranges by house size, and what pushes a price up, are in our roof replacement cost guide.
How long does each roof last in Victoria?
Lifespan decides the whole comparison, and it is the number most coloured by who publishes it. We lined up five sources side by side.
| Source | Who they are | Asphalt | Metal |
|---|---|---|---|
| InterNACHI life expectancy chart | Home inspectors' association | 30 years (architectural) | 40 to 80 years |
| Green Building Canada (2026) | Canadian building guide | 25 to 30 years (architectural) | 40 to 50 (shingle), 50 to 70 (standing seam) |
| Shoreline Roofing | Victoria roofer, installs both | 15 to 22 years in local conditions | 40 to 50 years |
| Forge Metal Roofing | Victoria roofer, metal only | 15 to 20 years | 40 to 70 years |
| Metal Roofing Alliance | Metal industry body | 12 to 20 years | 30 to 50+ years |
The closer a source sits to selling metal, the shorter it says asphalt lasts. Our working read for the South Island: 20 to 30 years for architectural asphalt in sun, toward 20 or under on north slopes under fir and cedar (where Shoreline's local figure sits), and 40-plus years for metal specified for its exposure.
Standing seam, metal shingle or exposed-fastener panel?
'Metal roof' covers three products at three prices, so pin down which one a quote means before you compare it with asphalt.
Standing seam is long flat panels joined by raised seams over hidden clips that let the steel expand and contract; Green Building Canada puts steel at $18 to $25 a square foot installed and aluminum at $22 to $30. Metal shingle is smaller pieces with concealed fasteners, shaped to look like shake or slate, at $12 to $18. Exposed-fastener panel, the corrugated or ribbed sheet screwed through its face, is the budget option: Forge lists corrugated at $8 to $14 in Victoria, and RenoQuotes describes exposed-fastener steel as common on cottages, outbuildings and rural homes. Every one of those screws is a hole sealed by a washer, which is the trade you make for the lower price.
Weighing metal against asphalt for your own house? We can quote both, side by side.
Get a written quoteIs metal cheaper per year than asphalt?
Only if your asphalt roof would wear out young. Take the 2,500 sq ft two-storey from our cost guide: about 1,680 sq ft of roof at the midpoint. At mid-band prices, asphalt is about $12,600 ($7.50 a sq ft), steel standing seam about $31,100 ($18.50) and steel metal shingle about $25,200 ($15).
Spread over 25 years, the asphalt roof costs about $500 a year. Standing seam over 50 years is about $620 a year, and metal shingle over 45 years about $560. Asphalt matches standing seam's yearly cost if it lasts about 20 years, and metal shingle's at about 22.5. Shorter than that, metal wins; longer, asphalt does.
That is our arithmetic on midpoints, with no inflation, financing or the disruption of a second tear-off counted. It swings hard on two lifespans nobody can promise, which is why the lot matters more than the brochure.
Which roof suits which South Island house?
Exposure and your time in the house decide more than the material's spec sheet does.
- Exposed waterfront (Oak Bay, Esquimalt, Sidney and Colwood shorelines). Wind and salt both work on the roof. Ask for the metal's warranty for your address: one US coil supplier's 2026 sample substrate warranty excludes panels within 1,500 ft (about 460 m) of breaking surf and 800 ft (about 245 m) of a large bay. Aluminum does not rust and costs more ($22 to $30 a sq ft). If you choose asphalt here, insist on the high-wind nailing pattern in writing.
- Sheltered, treed lot (much of Saanich, and any lot under Douglas fir or Garry oak). Shade and needles keep a roof damp through a year the City of Victoria's climate data puts at about 800 mm of rain. That is where asphalt falls short of its rated life and metal earns its premium.
- Open, sunny lot (many newer Langford and Colwood subdivisions). Asphalt dries between showers and has a fair chance at the long end of its range.
- Long-term owner. If you expect to stay 25 years or more, metal is likely the last roof you buy, and per year it runs close to even or better.
- Selling within about ten years. In the 2025 US Cost vs Value data, sellers in the Pacific region recouped about 76% of an asphalt re-roof and about 51% of a metal one. Those are US figures, not BC, but the gap holds the lesson: buyers pay back less of a metal premium.
When asphalt is the better buy
Asphalt is the right call on plenty of South Island roofs, and we say so when it is.
- You plan to sell within ten years. The cheaper roof leaves less unrecovered at sale.
- The roof gets sun most of the day and has never grown much moss.
- The roof is cut up with dormers, valleys and a chimney. Every cut is custom metal work, so the metal premium grows with complexity.
- The budget is fixed. At midpoint prices, asphalt costs about 40 percent of steel standing seam on the same roof.
- The house is heritage-designated in Victoria. Changing the roof material needs Council approval, and matching what is there is the simpler path.
- You want any roofer to be able to patch it in 15 years.
Read roof replacement for how we handle asphalt jobs and metal roofing for standing seam and metal shingle, then send your details through the quote form. We reply within one business day, and a written quote can price both materials on the same roof.

